COI is defined as follows: Had at any time a supervisor/PhD student relationship. Are both from the same institution, or have worked at the same institution in the past 3 years. Are currently working together on a research paper or project, or have done so during the past 3 years. Are related, or are close personal friends. Are in some form of financial relationship, or have been at some point during the past 3 years. Any other reason or circumstance that creates a risk that professional judgement may be unduly influenced.