| Year | Winner | Other Nominations |
|---|---|---|
| 1958 | The Incredible Shrinking Man | |
| 1959 | The Fly The Horror of Dracula The Seventh Voyage of Sinbad | |
| 1960 | Twilight Zone (TV) | Men into Space (TV) Murder and the Android (TV) The Turn of the Screw The World, the Flesh and the Devil |
| 1961 | Twilight Zone (TV) | The Time Machine Village of the Damned |
| 1962 | Twilight Zone (TV) | The Fabulous World of Jules Verne Thriller (TV) The Two Worlds of Charlie Gordon (TV) Village of the Damned |
| 1963 | Burn, Witch, Burn The Day the Earth Caught Fire Last Year at Marienbad Twilight Zone (TV) | |
| 1965 | Dr. Strangelove | The Seven Faces of Dr. Lao |
| 1967 | Star Trek: The Menagerie (TV) | Fahrenheit 451 Fantastic Voyage Star Trek: The Corbomite Maneuver (TV) Star Trek: The Naked Time (TV) |
| 1968 | Star Trek: City on the Edge of Forever (TV) | Star Trek: Amok Time (TV) Star Trek: Mirror, Mirror (TV) Star Trek: The Doomsday Machine (TV) Star Trek: The Trouble with Tribbles (TV) |
| 1969 | 2001: A Space Odyssey | Charly The Prisoner: Fallout (TV) Rosemary's Baby The Yellow Submarine |
| 1970 | TV Coverage of Apollo XI | The Bed-Sitting Room The Illustrated Man Marooned The Immortal |
| 1971 | Blows Against the Empire Colossus: The Forbin Project Don't Crush That Dwarf, Hand Me the Pliers (LP) Hauser's Memory No Blade of Grass | |
| 1972 | A Clockwork Orange | The Andromeda Strain I Think We're All Bozos on this Bus (LP) Los Angeles: A.D. 2017 (TV) |
| 1973 | Slaughterhouse Five | Between Time and Timbuktu (TV) Silent Running The People (TV) |
| 1974 | Sleeper | Genesis Two (TV) The Six-Million Dollar Man (TV) Soylent Green Westworld |
| 1975 | Young Frankenstein | |
| 1976 | A Boy and His Dog | |
| 1978 | Star Wars | |
| 1979 | Superman | |
| 1980 | Alien | The Black Hole The Muppet Movie Star Trek: The Motion Picture Time After Time |
| 1981 | The Empire Strikes Back | Cosmos Flash Gordon The Lathe of Heaven The Martian Chronicles (TV) |
| 1982 | Raiders of the Lost ark | Dragonslayer Excalibur Outland Time Bandits |
| 1983 | Blade Runner | Dark Crystal E.T.: The Extraterrestrial Mad Max 2 Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan |
| 1984 | Return of the Jedi | Brainstorm The Right Stuff Something Wicked This Way Comes Wargames |
| 1985 | 2010 | Dune Ghostbusters The Last Starfighter Star Trek III: The Search for Spock |
| 1986 | Back to the Future | Brazil Cocoon Enemy Mine Ladyhawke |
| 1987 | Aliens | The Fly Labyrinth Little Shop of Horrors Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home |
| 1988 | The Princess Bride | Predator Robocop The Witches of Eastwick Star Trek: The Next Generation: Encounter at Far Point |
| 1989 | Who Framed Roger Rabbit | Alien Nation Beetlejuice Big Willow |
| 1990 | Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade | The Abyss The Adventures of Baron Von Munchausen Batman Field of Dreams |
| 1991 | Edward Scissorhands | Back to the Future Part III Ghost Total Recall Witches |
| 1992 | Terminator 2: Judgment Day | The Addams Family Beauty and the Beast The Rocketeer Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country |
| 1993 | Star Trek: The Next Generation: The Inner Light (TV) | Aladdin Alien3 Batman Returns Bram Stoker's Dracula |
| 1994 | Jurassic Park | Addams Family Values Babylon 5: The Gathering (TV) Groundhog Day The Nightmare Before Christmas |
| 1995 | Star Trek: The Next Generation: All Good Things (TV) | Interview with the Vampire The Mask Star Trek: Generations Stargate |
| 1996 | Babylon 5: The Coming of Shadows (TV) | Apollo 13 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: The Visitor (TV) Toy Story Twelve Monkeys |
| 1997 | Babylon 5: Severed Dreams (TV) | Independence Day Mars Attacks! Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Trials and Tribble-ations (TV) Star Trek: First Contact |
| 1998 | Contact | The Fifth Element Gattaca Men in Black Starship Troopers |
| 1999 | Babylon 5: Sleeping in Light (TV) Dark City Pleasantville Star Trek: Insurrection The Truman Show |